(proposed by Bekhzod Kurbonboev, Institute of Mathematics, Tashkent)
Hint: (a) Multiply the equation by some power of A from left and another power of A from right.
(b) Substitute repeatedly X=A−AX−XA2.
Solution 1. First suppose that some matrix X satisfies the equation. We can obtain new equations if we multiply the given equation by some power of A from left and another power of A from right. For example,
A2(X+AX+XA2)A2=A2XA2+A3⋅XA2+A2XA⋅A3=A2XA2.
The right-hand side is
A2⋅A⋅A2=A3⋅A2=0, so
A2XA2A2XAXAXA2AXX=A2(X+AX+XA2)A2=A5=0.Similarly,=A2(X+AX+XA2)=A3=0=A(X+AX+XA2)A=A3=0=(X+AX+XA2)A2=A3=0=A(X+AX+XA2)A=A2.Finally=A−AX−XA2=A−A2.
Hence, no matrix other than A−A2 can satisfy the equation.
Note that the argument above does not prove that the matrix X=A−A2 satisfies the equation, because the steps cannot be done in reverse order. That must be verified separately. Indeed,
X+AX+XA2=(A−A2)+A(A−A2)+(A−A2)A2=A−A4=A.
Hence, X=A−A2 is the unique solution of the equation.
Remark. By multiplying the equation by An from left and by Ak from right we can get 9 different equations:
X+AX+XA2=AAX+A2X+AXA2=A2A2X+A2XA2=0XA+AXA=A2AXA+A2XA=0A2XA=0XA2+AXA2=0AXA2+A2XA2=0A2XA2=0
These formulas provide a system of linear equations for the nine matrices X, AX, A2X, XA, AXA, A2XA, XA2, AXA2 and A2XA2.
Solution 2. We use a different approach to express X in terms of A. If some matrix X satisfies the equation then
X=A−AX−XA2.
Let us substitute this identity in the right-hand side repeatedly until
X cancels out everywhere. Notice that by the condition
A3=0 we have
A3=A4=A5=A3X=XA4=AXA4=A3XA2=0, so
X=A−AX−XA2=A−A(A−AX−XA2)−(A−AX−XA2)A2=A−(A2−A2X−AXA2)−(A3−AXA2−XA4)=A−A2+A2X+2AXA2=A−A2+A2(A−AX−XA2)+2A(A−AX−XA2)A2=A−A2+(A3−A3X−A2XA2)+2(A4−A2XA2−AXA4)=A−A2−3A2XA2=A−A2−3A2(A−AX−XA2)A2=A−A2−3(A5−A3XA2−A2XA4)=A−A2.
To complete the solution, we have to verify that X=A−A2 is indeed a solution. This step is the same as in Solution 1.
Solution 3. Let B=I−A+A2 so that B is the inverse of I+A. Multiplying by B from the left, the equation is equivalent to
X+BXA2=BA.(1)
Now assume
X satisfies the equation. Multiplying by
A2 from the right and using
A3=0 we get
XA2=0. Hence the equation simplifies to
X=BA=A−A2.
On the other hand, X=BA obviously satisfies (1).
Μεταγραφή από το επίσημο κείμενο λύσεων, σελίδες 1–2. Η μεταγραφή δεν έχει ελεγχθεί δεύτερη φορά· αν έχεις αμφιβολία, κοίτα το πρωτότυπο.