(proposed by Nikolaos Kolliopoulos, University of Cyprus)
Solution 1. Let A=(aij)i,j=1n and B=(bij)i,j=1n. By taking traces of both sides,
0=tr(A⊤A+BB⊤−AB−BA)=tr(A⊤A)+tr(BB⊤)−tr(AB)−tr(BA)=i,j=1∑naij2+i,j=1∑nbji2−2i,j=1∑naijbji=i,j=1∑n(aij−bji)2.
Hence,
aij=bji for every
i,j, so
B=A⊤.
By substituting B=A⊤ back into the condition, we get
2BA=A⊤A+BB⊤=AB+BA,
so the answer is YES.
Remark. If B=A⊤ and AB=BA then A⊤A=AA⊤, so A must be a normal matrix. Then the condition is satisfied as
A⊤A+BB⊤=AB+BA=2AB.
Solution 2. Observe that the desired equality can be written as
(A−B⊤)⊤(A−B⊤)=AB−A⊤B⊤
where the left-hand side is a symmetric and non-negative definite matrix over
R, meaning that it has only real non-negative eigenvalues. On the other hand, for the right-hand side we can compute
tr(AB−A⊤B⊤)=tr(AB)−tr(A⊤B⊤)=tr(AB)−tr(BA)⊤=0.
Hence, the matrix
(A−B⊤)⊤(A−B⊤)=AB−A⊤B⊤ must have all its non-negative eigenvalues equal to
0, and because it is a symmetric matrix with real entries and thus a diagonalizable matrix, it has to be the zero matrix. This means that
A−B⊤=0 so that
A=B⊤. Then, the solution can be completed like in the first solution.
Μεταγραφή από το επίσημο κείμενο λύσεων, σελίδες 2–3. Η μεταγραφή δεν έχει ελεγχθεί δεύτερη φορά· αν έχεις αμφιβολία, κοίτα το πρωτότυπο.