(Proposed by Stephan Wagner, Stellenbosch University)
Solution 1. Let the matrix be
M=[xzzy].
The two conditions give us
x+y=a and
xy−z2=b. Since this is symmetric in
x and
y, the matrix can only be unique if
x=y. Hence
2x=a and
x2−z2=b. Moreover, if
(x,y,z) solves the system of equations, so does
(x,y,−z). So
M can only be unique if
z=0. This means that
2x=a and
x2=b, so
a2=4b.
If this is the case, then M is indeed unique: if x+y=a and xy−z2=b, then
(x−y)2+4z2=(x+y)2+4z2−4xy=a2−4b=0,
so we must have
x=y and
z=0, meaning that
M=[a/200a/2]
is the only solution.
Solution 2. Note that trace(M)=a and det(M)=b if and only if the two eigenvalues λ1 and λ2 of M are solutions of x2−ax+b=0. If λ1=λ2, then
M1=[λ100λ2]andM2=[λ200λ1]
are two distinct solutions, contradicting uniqueness. Thus
λ1=λ2=λ=a/2, which implies
a2=4b once again. In this case, we use the fact that
M has to be diagonalisable as it is assumed to be symmetric. Thus there exists a matrix
T such that
M=T−1⋅[λ00λ]⋅T,
however this reduces to
M=λ(T−1⋅I⋅T)=λI, which shows again that
M is unique.
Transcribed from the official solutions, pages 1–2. This transcription has not been checked a second time; if in doubt, look at the original.