Nilpotent and commuting matrices
When a matrix is nilpotent, what you gain when , and the trick .
Nilpotent matrices
is called nilpotent if for some . The following are equivalent:
- is nilpotent;
- all its eigenvalues are ;
- , hence (the exponent always suffices);
- for .
(4) ⇒ (2) comes from Newton's identities. If the non-zero eigenvalues were with multiplicities , then for , and the Vandermonde determinant gives . It needs characteristic (over , has ).
Inversion. If is nilpotent, is invertible with .
Commuting matrices
If in :
- Common eigenvector. Each eigenspace of is invariant under , so has an eigenvector inside it.
- Simultaneous triangularisation: there is with and upper triangular. Hence the eigenvalues of are and those of are , for a suitable matching.
- If both are diagonalisable, they are simultaneously diagonalisable.
- The binomial formulas hold: , and .
- The sum and the product of commuting nilpotent matrices are nilpotent.
The commutator always has trace . So is impossible (the trace would be ). If moreover commutes with , then is nilpotent. Proof: with and , we get , so for every , and (4) applies.
Passing to the complex numbers
For real with :
Special case : . Without the factorisation fails, because .
Other quick arguments for real matrices:
- For odd , every has a real eigenvalue, because has odd degree.
- If in , then , so is even.
Pitfalls
- Without , none of the above holds. and are nilpotent, but their sum has eigenvalues .
- needs commutativity. Don't write it without checking.
- In (4) you need all , not only .
Further reading
- Axler, Linear Algebra Done Right, 4th ed., §8A (Generalized Eigenvectors and Nilpotent Operators)
- Axler, Linear Algebra Done Right, 4th ed., §5E (Commuting Operators)
- Axler, Linear Algebra Done Right, 4th ed., §1B (Exercise 8: the complexification V_C)
- Axler, Linear Algebra Done Right, 4th ed., §3B (Exercise 33: the complexification T_C)
- Axler, Linear Algebra Done Right, 4th ed., §5A (Exercise 17: real eigenvalues of T and T_C)
Contest problems using these tools
No problems with these tools yet.