uniolympiads Ελληνικά

IMC 1996, Day 2, Problem 2

Let θ\theta be a positive real number and let cosh⁡t=et+e−t2\cosh t = \dfrac{e^t + e^{-t}}{2} denote the hyperbolic cosine. Show that if k∈Nk \in \mathbb{N} and both cosh⁡kθ\cosh k\theta and cosh⁡(k+1)θ\cosh(k+1)\theta are rational, then so is cosh⁡θ\cosh\theta.

Original from the official PDFe t + e −t denote the 2 hyperbolic cosine. Show that if k ∈ N and both cosh kθ and cosh (k + 1)θ are rational, then so is cosh θ. Let θ be a positive real number and let cosh t =

This transcription was compared symbol by symbol with the original, but not yet by a person.

Time on this problem 0:00

Work for at least 45 minutes before opening the solution.

Official solution

Solution. First we show that

If cosh⁡t is rational and m∈N, then cosh⁡mt is rational.(1)\text{If } \cosh t \text{ is rational and } m \in \mathbb{N}, \text{ then } \cosh mt \text{ is rational.} \tag{1}

Since cosh⁡0.t=cosh⁡0=1∈Q\cosh 0.t = \cosh 0 = 1 \in \mathbb{Q} and cosh⁡1.t=cosh⁡t∈Q\cosh 1.t = \cosh t \in \mathbb{Q}, (1) follows inductively from

cosh⁡ (m+1)t=2cosh⁡t.cosh⁡mt−cosh⁡ (m−1)t.\cosh\,(m+1)t = 2\cosh t.\cosh mt - \cosh\,(m-1)t.

The statement of the problem is obvious for k=1k = 1, so we consider k≥2k \geq 2. For any m we have

cosh⁡θ=cosh⁡ ((m+1)θ−mθ)==cosh⁡ (m+1)θ.cosh⁡mθ−sinh⁡ (m+1)θ.sinh⁡mθ=cosh⁡ (m+1)θ.cosh⁡mθ−cosh⁡2(m+1)θ−1.cosh⁡2mθ−1(2)\begin{aligned} \cosh\theta &= \cosh\,((m+1)\theta - m\theta) = \\ &= \cosh\,(m+1)\theta.\cosh m\theta - \sinh\,(m+1)\theta.\sinh m\theta \\ &= \cosh\,(m+1)\theta.\cosh m\theta - \sqrt{\cosh^2(m+1)\theta - 1}.\sqrt{\cosh^2 m\theta - 1} \end{aligned} \tag{2}

Set cosh⁡kθ=a\cosh k\theta = a, cosh⁡ (k+1)θ=b\cosh\,(k+1)\theta = b, a,b∈Qa, b \in \mathbb{Q}. Then (2) with m=km = k gives

cosh⁡θ=ab−a2−1b2−1\cosh\theta = ab - \sqrt{a^2 - 1}\sqrt{b^2 - 1}

and then

(a2−1)(b2−1)=(ab−cosh⁡θ)2=a2b2−2abcosh⁡θ+cosh⁡2θ.(3)\begin{aligned} (a^2 - 1)(b^2 - 1) &= (ab - \cosh\theta)^2 \\ &= a^2 b^2 - 2ab\cosh\theta + \cosh^2\theta. \end{aligned} \tag{3}

Set cosh⁡ (k2−1)θ=A\cosh\,(k^2 - 1)\theta = A, cosh⁡k2θ=B\cosh k^2\theta = B. From (1) with m=k−1m = k - 1 and t=(k+1)θt = (k+1)\theta we have A∈QA \in \mathbb{Q}. From (1) with m=km = k and t=kθt = k\theta we have B∈QB \in \mathbb{Q}. Moreover k2−1>kk^2 - 1 > k implies A>aA > a and B>bB > b. Thus AB>abAB > ab. From (2) with m=k2−1m = k^2 - 1 we have

(A2−1)(B2−1)=(AB−cosh⁡θ)2=A2B2−2ABcosh⁡θ+cosh⁡2θ.(4)\begin{aligned} (A^2 - 1)(B^2 - 1) &= (AB - \cosh\theta)^2 \\ &= A^2 B^2 - 2AB\cosh\theta + \cosh^2\theta. \end{aligned} \tag{4}

So after we cancel the cosh⁡2θ\cosh^2\theta from (3) and (4) we have a non-trivial linear equation in cosh⁡θ\cosh\theta with rational coefficients.

Transcribed from the official solutions, pages 10–11. This transcription has not been checked a second time; if in doubt, look at the original.

Archive problem: the statement is the official text (transcribed, with the original above). Subject classification and difficulty were estimated automatically; hints and a worked solution are added over time.

How did it go?